What Would Piss Red Sox Nation Off More?

Assuming that the Dodgers play the Sox in the World Series (I think the Rays make it but lets pretend) which would piss the Sox fans off more.

Losing to the Manny led Dodgers or winning and then having to give Manny a ring since he was on the team this year?

Personally I am over Boston and their winning ways (mainly because of Bill Simmon's douchebaggery) but I have to admit it would be highly entertaining to see Manny show up at the ring ceremony next year and all the drama that would ensue.